“The Wrong Nemesis,” is the first episode in season 2. With new husband Webb now deceased, Robin stands to inherit a fortune with a little help from Sheldon, the family’s lawyer. Carrie’s philanthropic endeavors have always taken a backseat to the family’s business ones, but now, with Lance at her side, she plans to expand her role. Kayla is enjoying the single life until she meets Carter, whom she quickly falls for, and lest she be overshadowed, Tara begins an affair with her teacher.

Nobody, least of all Pam, knows how to handle her long-lost daughter Eve, so they ask Sheldon for his counsel. The more Eve is brought into the fold, the more it rankles Tara, who doesn't believe Eve is who she says she is. Robin meets with a duplicitous boat owner; all of this pales in comparison to the biggest shock of all: Webb is alive, and whatever he wants, it can't be good for the family.

The family is frantic about Webb’s return. Despite the previous tension between Pam and Stephen Napoli, they rekindle their romance in the spirit of working together to uncover Webb’s true intentions. Meanwhile, Tara travels to England to dig into Eve’s background. Carrie and Lance have a very public blow-up, sending Lance right back into the arms of his father, Webb. Or so it appears.

William French has a diabolical plan to reunite with Kayla; Tara displays her smarts once again when she discovers Eve's true identity and motive; Webb falls for Lance's ruse hook, line, and sinker. The matriarch of the Jones family, Robin Jones, has been threatened by a mysterious woman via a video call.